Most people never watch their tree being pruned. They come home to a tidy yard, a chipped pile of brush and a tree that looks lighter, and they assume it went well. The damage from a bad job rarely shows that week. It shows the next season, in a flush of weak shoots where the cuts were, in bark that won’t close over a wound, or in a limb that fails in a storm three years later.
The short answer: good pruning takes no more than a quarter of the living crown at once, and leaves clean cuts just outside the branch collar, never flush with the trunk and never as stubs. It happens at the right time of year for that species, and it never involves topping a tree. If you can see stubs, torn bark or a tree cut back to thick amputated limbs, the job was done badly.
What pruning is actually for
Pruning is done for a handful of reasons. For mature trees the University of Maryland Extension lists controlling size, providing clearance for foot traffic or vehicles, removing potentially hazardous branches, and improving appearance, and it says separately to “Remove damaged, diseased, and dead branches at any time”. In practice that means:
- Removing wood that is already lost: dead or diseased branches, and branches broken by storms.
- Controlling size, where a tree has outgrown the space it stands in.
- Improving appearance, which is its own legitimate reason and not a lesser one.
- Build structure on young trees. This is the part most people skip, and it is the part that matters most. The University of Maryland Extension puts it plainly: “Young trees frequently need pruning to establish a beneficial branch structure”, and “If properly pruned when young, mature trees seldom need major pruning” (University of Maryland Extension).
A newly planted tree is the exception to all of this. The same guidance says newly planted trees “should be pruned only when there are broken or damaged branches”. Leave the rest of the canopy alone while it establishes.
How much should come off
No more than one-fourth of the living crown should be removed at any one time (University of Maryland Extension). That single figure is the easiest thing for a homeowner to check.
When branches are being removed from the bottom to raise the canopy over a driveway or roof, the limit works the other way: at least two-thirds of the tree’s total height must still carry living branches.
If a quote describes taking “about half” the canopy off a mature tree, that is outside what the guidance allows, whatever it is called.
One more rule sits alongside this. The Extension’s wording is that “Stressed trees should not be pruned since all leaves are important for recovery”, though it adds that “diseased, broken, or dead branches should be removed”. So a drought-stressed or recently transplanted tree still gets its hazards taken out; what it does not get is shaping or thinning while it recovers.
Montclair, NJ
Not sure your tree was pruned properly?
We can look at the cuts, the wounds and what has grown since.
What a correct cut looks like
Two things tell you most of what you need to know.
The cut is not flush with the trunk. At the base of every branch is a slightly swollen collar. The University of Maryland Extension describes it as “an area of natural shedding that contains chemically protective tissue”, and the instruction is blunt: “Never cut the branch flush with the trunk, thus removing the branch collar.” A flush cut takes that tissue away.
There are no stubs. A branch cut partway along, leaving a projecting length of deadwood, gives the tree nothing to seal against. The stub dies back and decay works inward from it.
So after the work is done, walk around and look at the cut ends. The Extension’s finishing cut on a large branch is made “perpendicular to the trunk on the branch side of the collar”, so what you want to see is the raised collar still there, with the cut just beyond it. What you do not want is a flat face cut tight against the bark, torn strips of bark hanging below a cut, or short dead spikes left behind.
Topping: the one to refuse outright
Topping is cutting a tree back by lopping off large branches or whole tops, leaving stubs. It is still sold, usually to people worried about a big tree near a house, and the Extension’s guidance on it is two words long.
Those words are “Never top”. Two reasons follow in the same source. Topping “causes the growth of many weak suckers that may break off when they become heavy branches”, which the source describes as “causing a possibly hazardous situation”. And “Wood rots are more likely to be a problem in topped trees”.
A related practice, tipping, cuts lateral branches between nodes rather than back to a node or crotch. The Extension calls it “another procedure that should not be used”.
If a tree genuinely has too much weight in the wrong place, the honest options are a proper reduction made at the right points, support for a weak union, or professional pruning and removal. Topping is none of those.
Worried a tree was topped or cut badly? Call our Montclair office for a look.
When pruning should happen
Timing depends on the species, and the general rules are simple enough to check against a quote:
- Trees that flower on old wood, such as serviceberry, redbud and dogwood, are pruned immediately after they finish blooming. Prune them in winter and the flower buds go with the cuttings.
- Trees that bleed sap when cut in late winter include birch, maple, dogwood, elm, walnut and yellowwood. The Extension says the bleeding “is not harmful to the tree”, so this is about appearance rather than health: pruning in late fall or early winter, or after spring growth finishes in May or June, avoids it.
- Dogwood is on both lists, which is a good illustration of why species matters more than a calendar rule. Ask what is being pruned and why before the date is set.
- Stressed trees get their dead, diseased and broken branches removed, and nothing more until they recover.
For what that means month by month in this area, there is a local guide to when to prune trees in Montclair.
The structural problem pruning can’t fix later
A tree that divides into two trunks of roughly equal size is weaker where they meet than a tree with one main trunk. On a young tree the fix is a single cut and it lasts: the Extension’s advice is that if a tree has codominant stems, “remove one to avoid structural weakness”. It also describes what happens when the two stems grow tightly together, where “the bark becomes enclosed within the crotch, which leads to weakness and branch failure or dieback”.
On a mature tree, that is no longer a pruning job. Removing one of two full-sized trunks would take half the tree. At that point the question becomes whether the union can be supported instead, which is the question cabling and bracing answer.
What this company prunes
American Tree Experts lists aesthetic pruning, crown reduction, crown thinning, dead pruning and hazard pruning among its services, and its pruning and removals page states that the work is done “according to the standards put down by the International Society of Arboriculture and the New Jersey Board of Certified Tree Experts”.
When it stops being a homeowner job
The line is clear in the Extension’s guidance: “Pruning large trees and any tree work that requires climbing or near power lines is dangerous” and “should be performed by a licensed tree expert or certified arborist”.
Two things are worth adding. The first is that height is not the only factor. A modest limb hanging over a roof, a fence or the power line into the house has to be lowered under control, which is a different job from simply reaching it. The second is that pruning cuts made in the wrong place cannot be undone; the tree lives with them for the rest of its life. There is more on why hiring a pruning service beats DIY if you are weighing it up.
Healthy trees can withstand occasional pest attacks without being damaged. Water and fertilize your trees regularly. Add mulch and prune throughout the year.
It works in combination with manganese to convert nitrogen.
Just by following good tree care practices, you can keep insects and pests away.
Trimming and pruning is an essential annual tree care practice. Pruning dead, diseased, and unsafe tree branches allow you to protect yourself, your home, and your belongings. In addition, it keeps the tree in the proper structure and shape.
The tree removal company’s job is to ensure it performs an excellent post-removal cleanup at the property. It is always a good idea to confirm with your selected company if they will include this in their removal service or charge you extra.
The Magnolia Cucumbertree is known for its excellent leaf cover and shade. It can help cool down your home and yard if grown at a good location. Homeowners love to relax under the shadow of this tree.
The Northern Catalpa tree is also commonly known as the Catawba tree. It is a very common tree, to the point that it is considered a weed in certain places. The tree’s leaves are heart-shaped and large which is an amazing sight. The tree produces fluffy white flowers and long and skinny seed pods and usually has a lot of
Stump Grinding is a quicker process as compared to stump removal. Unless you are specifically trained and have previous experience, we would not recommend doing it as a DIY project. It is best to hire a professional company.
